Creating a working/training/character test - what should it look like?
I plan to watch a working aptitude evaluation for Dobermans, sponsored by a local doberman club next month. Dogs that pass the exam receive a certificate saying that they have "working aptitude". Here is an example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBoWSuQWf-U And of course, we are all familiar with schutzhund/IPO work. I am starting to think of what a "breed specific exam" might look like for our breed. I think it should include these components:
1. SVP test 2. Tracking (or trailing?) test 3. Obedience test Since bonitation is a one time event, I would keep that seperate, I think... Should protection be a part of the exam? I like the scenarios in the Doberman temperament evaluation - portions of it remind me of the temperament portion of the Czech bonitation I was very lucky to attend. Would this short temperament test be a more reasonable test than the more involved and precise protection exams of schutzhund/IPO? I like the ideas of increasing levels of difficulty as well (like IPO 1, IPO 2, IPO 3). Is there anything else that should be included? Thoughts? :) Just daydreaming of the day we have any such breed specific exams in the USA...I love working with my dogs!:p |
Quote:
|
in Finland all working test have obedience test also. (like in tracking JK1,JK2,JK3 classes) Normal you need passed obedience first then you can go tracking...
This is tracking obe JK3 class http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHGFH...eature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRZCyEnxoIg That obediense is different than Real Obedience test (open to all breeds) Rescue tracking and rescue search are total different also. |
this is normal typical IPO B obedience test.
|
I think there should be a few character/work tests available. Depending on where the dog lives, what is expected from him/her and what the owner considers crucial for the behaviour in a particular setting their could select 2-3 out of 6-7 approved and standardized tests to take and get a "character/work certifiate". This could be defence, OB, tracking/trailing, endurance runs, "socialisation" ie. Dog Citizen Exam, agility, herding, etc.
I think it's unfair to test all the dogs against ONE criterion, if they live in so many different environments and so different kinds of behaviour are expected from them. |
Workingtest is total different than charactertest.
I know very many dogs who have working tittles but doesn´t passed FCI charactertest. |
Quote:
As far as the test goes, I like the ideas Marcy's already mentioned. I would either leave off protection, or add a separate test for it that you can obtain an additional title in. I think ALL CsV should be able to pass endurance, obedience, and trailing, but that protection should be more of a case by case basis. Just my 2 cents. :) |
I don't see any way to check all drives witch balansed, working dog should have, without defense test. Bonitation character test is in my opinion too primitiv because don't answer for a question why dog attack. On wich drive he do it. And this test promote avoidance agresion.
|
I don't agree. I'll never train my dog for defence! Since Lorka arrived to our home I've taught her she should have a very balanced attitude to humans - no jumping, no grapsing - just indifferent or friendly attitude. I walk my dog in busy streets several times a day, let her unleashed in the city common, take her by buses and trams, go to crowded cafes and friendly stores with her. She is used to walking among people who look all differently, with sticks, strange luggage, etc. etc.
I must be sure she'd never want to play "defence game" with anybody. This is my absolute priority! Thus I don't feel like mixing in my dog's head just to pass some test. I saw wofldogs that do very well on the sleeve, but their owners warn people they should not approach them! |
we speak about test or exam? this are big diferent.
|
Baron spod Dumbiera, Ikala spod Dumbiera, Bono z Holstejna and Andradite Rocks´n Jewels have passed FCI character test whit out any training and that test tell only what kind your dog character is.
all my dog can walk whit me in the city like 2 weeks ago in Kaunas centrum whit out any problems but all can´t passed that character test. ;-) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ED-pK...eature=related |
Rona but it will be test for working dogs not a pets...
|
Quote:
Satu - yes this is good test for character. I in this year have posibility work in ZTP doberman test- and .. they tested a TRAINING not character test- work a 1-3 year and all dogs pas this. This is test for character? no this is test for good trainer and training posibility. If we speak about CSv for him mas be test with tracking - natural tracking not IPO. |
Dogs breed using ZTP and IPO and have similar or better quality after few generations. Dogs breed using bonitation test as charakter test and SVP as working test are worst and worst. So mayby something is wrong with the tests?
|
Quote:
|
good evening to all :)
i didn't understand what do you want to create - character test or test of working abilities/training level? for example if my dog is trained for search and rescue and he can't show any kind of agression, how he would pass test like ipo? will it show that the dog is not good or what? :roll: |
Quote:
Besides, for me there is a huge difference between work and sport. Some train their dogs for sports and exams only, others - for work. I mean real work. |
In uk working trials, as far as I'm aware, the defence/protection part is optional, rather than required.
So you can do the obedience, tracking etc, without the bite work if you want to. Taz |
In the US, we use the following terms:
Trial = Obedience, Schutzhund (all parts) Test = Tracking (AKC), Canine Good Citizen (Character test) A character test is very short, and I agree, it doesn't necessarily show the drive of the dog (or rather, it maybe trained or misinterpreted). Also, I agree that not all dogs need/should be trained in protection. Also I agree that "sport" dogs maybe totally different than what a handler desires, even in protection - working more from a prey drive than defense, and maybe not as serious or "sleeve happy" (only wanting to bite a sleeve). We are in a position now of introducing our breed to the AKC. We have requested to join the "Working" group (instead of herding) - AKC also plans to "realign" it's groups, and the working group will be split into 3 - spitz/northern, mollesar and working utility. We hope to be included in "working utility", which includes multi-purpose breeds with a variety of jobs, from a variety of background. AKC wants to know what kind of work/tests/trials we plan to breed, train and compete towards. It is kind of a neat thing to be able to create exactly what we want in terms of tests or trials...but also very important to be headed in the right direction! I think a CSV specific trial should maybe look like: Part 1: Obedience Part 2: Natural tracking/trailing (AKC tracking is a "hybrid" of IPO and trailing - the dog must take all corners, but may "cast" off of the trail very far - there are no points given, only a "pass" (if the scent article is found), or a "fail" - in more advanced levels, the track is 3-5 hours old, much longer, obstacles such as water, and more scent articles. We also have a tracking test for urban/city environments. A test for CSV might focus more on a faster time, and less on "exactness" of following the tracks - more like trailing. Part 3: Endurance (something like SVP, but also maybe something else - dependent upon local terrain - like a course through mountain trails, for instance) Optional test (sort of like an FH or AD in schutzhund): Protection Seperate Character test (or maybe mandatory to participate in the : a. test specific to the CSV (I look forward to seeing Wolfin's new test that she referred to!) - this should be included with bonitation b. minimum - Canine Good Citizen test (to ensure civility of the dog in public situations) At least in the USA, it is possible to compete in many sports, including tracking, obedience, agility, rally obedience, dock diving, therapy work, nosework (scent detection) - and since recently, an aptitude test for lure-coursing and herding - for all breeds. So I don't think it should be a problem for anyone who wishes to try and (or all!) of these. I have already sent the AKC these videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQPFtilcgFY http://www.swr.de/im-gruenen-rp/-/id=100810/did=5436364/pv=video/nid=100810/4meu2n/index.html http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WhEE6Sn4wPM&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIpdkX5DQ0E&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T7kuDvtM2P0&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOeTJX6u6S8 |
All times are GMT +2. The time now is 23:36. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
(c) Wolfdog.org