|
Health and nutrition How to feed a Wolfdog, information about dog food, how to vaccinate and what to do if the dog gets ill.... |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
24-08-2009, 20:28 | #1 |
Moderator
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 583
|
Elbow Dysplasia
I have one question to you all here: if the heart illness would be found by your dogs would you breed with them? With the explanation "my dog have hearth problems but other people who breed do not check it and it is possible their dogs are also ill"?
The dogs was removed because in the most cases the elbow problem were hidden by their owners and elbow problems start to spread among the breed. While before there were also none known cases of ED-dysplasia it is getting more and more problematic and every month I'm getting information about new ED-infected dogs. The main difference between HD and ED is: ED is considered as be higher heriditary than HD. While using HD-free dogs you can only reduce the number of HD-infected puppies. The same method in the case of ED (using ED-free dogs) almost guaranty ED-free puppies. And vice versa: breeding with the ED-infected dogs almost guaranty some ED-infected puppies in a litter. None method is perfect but if the case of using both parents with ED-problems you will get 40% of puppies with elbow problems and if one of the parents is ED-infected still 13% will have ED-problems (according OFA). High number compared to HD where the heredity is much lower and the influence of other factors bigger. When you will look into the database (maybe Margo or elf can prepare some statistisc) you will see that most ED-affected dogs belong to the same "family" and have common ancestors; and their offsprings also are ED-affected. Nobody can forbid the breeding with ED-dogs but if you like it or not you must take into consideration that by using ED-infected dogs the problem will spread out. According to the researches it seems that removing ED-dogs from the group of breeding dogs can give fast very good results and it can reduce the number of ED-infected dogs to the number when we can say again "Czechoslovakian Wolfdogs DO NOT have problems with elbows". It is up to you if you will use such dogs for breeding. We just give you the advice "it seems to be a bad idea". |
24-08-2009, 22:16 | #2 | |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
Quote:
....Just some thoughts ! Rolf |
|
24-08-2009, 22:33 | #3 | |||
Moderator
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 583
|
Quote:
Second: if you remove dogs with results worser than HD-A you will loose a lot of interesting blood. If you remove all dogs with ED-problems you loose NOTHING. It is simple calculation. Quote:
Quote:
I know it is painfull information for you because as I see Voice is half-brother of your dogs but I hope you will understand this steps because according to the information written on Internet we can really cause visible improvement of the ED-results in some lines if we will remove not healthy dogs. |
|||
24-08-2009, 23:16 | #4 | |||||
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I test my dogs more than most people Quote:
Rolf Last edited by Juniorwolf; 24-08-2009 at 23:35. |
|||||
24-08-2009, 23:34 | #5 |
Moderator
|
Rolf, could you please quote the exactly moment where Admin wrotes that the dogs without results will stay in the list of Stud dogs? I really didn't find it, so I believe that all dogs without ED results will lso be removed from the list.
So far seems that the datas on some places of the webpage are not actualized because its still the old page.
__________________
|
25-08-2009, 00:01 | #6 | |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
Quote:
"If you mate two HD-free dogs you will still get some puppies with worser results (dysplatic). When you mate two ED-free dogs you can almost be sure that ALL puppies will be healthy." This frase makes me think that HD is worser than ED when speaking about heriditary diseases, but ofcourse I am not an expert Rolf |
|
25-08-2009, 08:58 | #7 | |
Moderator
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 583
|
Quote:
According to the new researches VERY high influence on the HD-result have the external factors like conditions where the puppy lives, feeding and so on. So breeding with HD-free dogs only will not have big influence on the results in the population. I think better results we will get if the breeders will breed "natural" looking dogs where puppies look skinny like real wolves and not like fat "tanks" which we can see so frequently at the moment /where the hips are overloaded and can not develop properly/. In opposition to this the ED seems to be mostly caused by genetic factors - as I wrote you can see it in the database that is is a problem of one or two CzW families - ED appear mostly by dogs comming from the same ancestors. |
|
25-08-2009, 09:33 | #8 | |||
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
why do you edit my text when you quote it ?
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Again I must say(with the chance to for this to be deleted in the next qoute), I am NOT an expert ! HD and ED is the same thing in different places of the body, I am sorry but I have never heard of any sientific test who proved that HD is more effected by external factors than ED is ? in fact, the differences between these two illneses I can only take your word for it is true... and as I can see above, your assumptions is not always true ! Rolf |
|||
25-08-2009, 09:50 | #9 |
Senior Member
|
Hi Rolf. One very short (and maybe stupid) question. Can you buy for you for example puppy from mother with czech HD result D (3/3) and italian B? If this puppy will be health (A or B), will you breed him?
|
25-08-2009, 10:43 | #10 | |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
Quote:
I don`t care from which country HD results is made as I have no knowledge of which countries/vets. is better or worse to make exact HD resuts. When I buy a puppy or choose to use my own dogs for breeding, I leave all questions about health to people who I trust have enough experience/knowledge about this and don`t worry any more about it. HD D is not allowed to breed in Denmark(I think in all FCI countries?). Rolf |
|
25-08-2009, 10:56 | #11 |
Senior Member
|
I hope in other countries too
I wont only this answer. |
25-08-2009, 11:43 | #12 | |
Distinguished Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 2,939
|
the thing that more it makes me become sad it is the fact that I personally have asked more times an answer to my questions in this thread, but there has been need of a particular and correct intervention from Rolf (message n°8 ) to make to answer the amministrator, this it is sad.
The dog in matter is Voice of wolf, my dog with HD A and ED 0-1 and not ED 1-1 before thing to be clarified. Second thing I don't absolutely agree that HD C is not similar to ED 1-1 (and what however it doesn't concern my dog that has ED 0 -1). Besides I don't know with what statistics you work, but the displasia of the hip derives from a genetic factor, stings. The environmental factor can worsen only a pup that however he could be carrier, also in least part. Of sure all the pups should grow with a correct environmental factor because he is not able' never to know, but if a pup genetically has ancestors without displasia the pup he is healthy, he is genetically almost impossible that the factor environmental harbors displasia to a healthy pup of this illness. But the thing most important it is not these thoughts of mine or yours that can be lined up or no. The fundamental thing is that if there are some rules they must be correct and correct for all the dogs. Quote:
You of the site have made your calculations and studies. I am able not to agree but being a site tried me I must respect the rules and I don't have problem. Voice of wolf is a dog that cannot be on the stud list, ok there is no problem. But they must have removed all the dogs that don't have the official plates of the elbows. Before sended the plates of Voice at center of official reading, I knew that 1 elbow was not perfect and I could only to make official the HDs. Instead I am correct and I have furnished to you some site the Official information. Then, I repeat him: if there are some rules in a private site they must have respected even if I don't agree. But the rules must be equal for everybody, otherwise the site loses the credibility. And it would be a sin. Last edited by Ricky's Wolf; 25-08-2009 at 11:47. |
|
25-08-2009, 18:28 | #13 | |
fica secca
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Treviso
Posts: 640
|
Quote:
It is unjust! Hanka I like your work and your seriousness, but whenI go to made HD results for my dog, I go to University of Padova (where there are famous and important teachers and studies on displasy) they tell me immediately that she is sure A and than this results go to the ufficial reading central (there are only two central in Italy) and the ufficial results is A. If what you say would be true, in Italy all dogs will be A or B, but it isn't the real situation! There is also C, D and E. What dogs did you know that have mistake results?
__________________
Serena&Rory Last edited by SERENA; 25-08-2009 at 19:34. |
|
25-08-2009, 18:36 | #14 |
Senior Member
|
Hello Serewolf, for me is sad, much wolfdogs is in breeding without HD results. So I think, they have bad HD result. It is not under ENCI. It is bad for breed.
This question what I wrote was special for Rolf |
25-08-2009, 18:50 | #15 |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
For the moment, all you have to do in Denmark to breed with a CSW,
is to get a 2. place at an international dogshow, nothing more... So if you don`t make official xrays, you can breed with all CSW`s in Denmark does`nt matter if the dog have strong HD, ED or other illnesses. I hope to change that in the near future, but things take time ! Rolf |
25-08-2009, 20:20 | #16 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
If this is the decision of the administration of Wolfdog.org, let it be (i'm not sooo much against it actually) But, I kindly ask the Admin if it's possible to write, for more and better knowledge of the viewers, the criteria used to make the list and what makes you be excluded. Also... could the Admin kindly state if ALL the dogs included in the list have HD results sent to Wolfdog.org (as always requested in the past?) or just ... announced by email from the owner. Thanks Massimo
__________________
---------- Oliver & Lunatica |
|
25-08-2009, 20:33 | #17 | |
Moderator
|
Quote:
We can't compare ED 1 with HD C as the dog with ED 1 already shows the degeneration, when a dog with HD C can have perfect bones with no degeneration, but only not nice norberg angles.
__________________
|
|
25-08-2009, 20:49 | #18 | |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 575
|
Quote:
Maybe I am stupid, but HD = Hip Dysplasia and ED = Elbow Dysplasia, so it is Dysplasia in the hips and in the elbows, how come one is worser than another, I mean it is the same thing, but in different places, so the degree of how bad or good it is, must be in the scales HD = A, B, C, etc. and ED = 0/0, 1/1, 2/2, etc. ? ...or am I totally wrong ? Rolf |
|
25-08-2009, 20:51 | #19 | ||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Did you buy a puppy from a female who had HD made in Italy and was B? I saw the xrays with my eyes, and the Italian documents behind it. That is enough for me. According to someone it seems that she had in Czech D(3/3)... Now I make a stupid question: HD X rays of czech dogs made outside Czech republic because afraid of results given by Dr Sterc are ok? Really...I would avoid throwing shit on others (as already mentioned by Edit...) it's not healthy and somehow it comes back to you. If you doubt Italian X rays (and one in particular) then if we start doubting ALL Xrays made in other countries different than Czech.... you lost your road completely. I can show you how HD results are given in Italy...I am curious to see the Czech paperwork! HD A http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2489/...4556b39b3a.jpg ED 0 http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3435/...4c827d9162.jpg HD D http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2581/...d36d5d812b.jpg ED 0 http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2472/...7284e124d2.jpg
__________________
---------- Oliver & Lunatica |
||
25-08-2009, 22:52 | #20 | |
Gran figl de putt Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 2,638
|
Quote:
Definizione scientifica dell'HD: La displasia dell'anca intesa come degenerazione articolare dell'anca su base genetica è una malformazione coxo-femorale. E' una patologia poligenica e multifatoriale. Poligenica perchè molti geni intervengono nella sua manifestazione, diverse tipologie di controllo genico governano questo poligenismo, dalla comune Dominanza, Recessione, Compenetrazione Parziale o Completa nonche l'Epistasi (fenomeno per cui un tale gene in un determinato loci può influire nel comportamento di un'altro gene in un'altro loci) Multifattoriale perchè la sua espressione è fortemente legata alle influenze ambientali come stile di vita, traumi ed alimentazione. E' scientificamente provato e riconosciuto che i fattori ambientali possono solo influire sulla modulazione e sull'espressione della patologia. Un cane geneticamente sano non può soffrire di displasia dell'anca per un influenza ambientale. L'influenza ambientale può far si che un cane geneticamente predisposto, manifesti solo un'imperfezione (HD-B, in Italia definita anche sospetta displasia) o una grave espressione della stessa (HD-E). E' altresi errato affermare che lo stile di allevamento possa generare cani displasici per sola influenza ambientale. Un fattore ambientale nocivo nel cucciolo può in un cane geneticamente sano per quanto riguarda HD, provocare una degenerazione artrosica dell'anca (dovuta a traumi e infezioni batteriche, ect ect), molto simile all'HD per sintomi, ma ben distinguibile nell'esame radiografico. La displasia del gomito è una patologia più facilmente eradicabile rispetto all'HD, perchè è governata da un solo gene di controllo semplice o Mendeliano, nella fattispecie è un gene Dominante quindi, per le leggi di Mendel, per eradicare un gene dominante è sufficiente eliminare dalla riproduzione il soggetto che presenta quel determinato fenotipo. Ovvero il soggetto che possiede il gene della displasia del gomito, presenta la patologia a livello fenotipico. Nella displasia dell'anca, un soggetto sano fenotipicamente può avere un patrimonio genetico altamente predisposto a trasmettere la displasia e quindi non è sufficiente riprodurre sulla base del fenotipo dei genitori. La stima del valore genetico (genetica quantitativa) è il metodo che fino ad oggi ha dato maggiori risultati, ma si basa su enormi e accurati notizie fenotipiche, calcoli genetici e correzioni matematiche atte a considerare i fattori ambientali nell'espressione della patologia. La nuova frontiera (ne ha parlato recentemente Ina) è una ricerca sui marcatori genetici, o microsatelliti, ovvero delle conformazioni ricorrenti nella sequenza del DNA. Per spiegare in poche parole, questa ricerca non individua i geni responsabili, ma delle configurazioni ricorrenti (ovveri dei "disegni", marcatori nella stringa del DNA) direttamente collegate all'espressione della patologia. E' sempre un metodo indiretto come la stima del valore genetico, ma molto più semplice e più rapido nel caso di un buon numero di campioni di DNA. - Atti del 1° Convegno Cinoflilo Nazionale 6 dicembre 2008 "La displasia dell'anca e nuovi criteri nella selezione dei riproduttori" relatore dott. Pedrani CELEMASCHE -Missiva del dott. Vezzoni FSA -articolo del dott. Asnaghi CELEMASCHE -"Metodi di Miglioramento Genetico in Cinologia" Università di Pisa Leotta 2004 -"Genetic for Dog Breeders" Robinson 1990 affermare che allevare i cuccioli magri come lupi, sia un metodo di miglioramento nell'incisività della displasia dell'anca è scientificamente errato! Concordo nell'allevare i cuccioli nel modo più naturale possibile, ma non per motivi legati alla displasia dell'anca!
__________________
IO CE L'HO PROFUMATO Last edited by woland77; 25-08-2009 at 22:58. |
|
|
|